Answers: WD Elements vs. Passport and Seagate Expansion vs. GoFlex

↓ Sponsored Links / Updated: May 10, 2015 / Home » Computer PC Hardware » Reviews

best portable USB hard disk quality comparison

best portable USB hard disk quality comparison

Which is the best portable USB hard disk brand in term of quality and reliability for backup? I purchased lots of hard disk and based on my own experience, two of the most reliable brands are WD and Seagate. Toshiba and Hitachi are the worst, my advice is to avoid HP, Acer, Buffalo, LG, Samsung, and more. Go for companies that specialize in a specific field, for instant, Bosch for the hardware tools, or Linksys for networking and so on.

Recommended Reading: WD Passport Smartware Backup and Password Protect Hard Disk Review

ModelFailedStill Working
WD Elements 2.5'028
WD Passport 2.5'03
WD Blue 2.5' (Sony Laptops replacement)02
WD Elements 3.5'01
WD My Book Essential 3.5'01
Seagate Expansion 2.5'1 (less than a month)4
Seagate GoFlex 2.5'01
Seagate Barracuda 3.5'04
Toshiba 2.5' (Sony Laptops)2 (less than 1 year)0
Hitachi 2.5' (Acer Laptop)1 (worked for 3 years)0

best portable USB hard disk quality comparison

best portable USB hard disk quality comparison

What are the difference between WD elements vs. passport and Seagate Expansion vs. FreeAgent GoFlex? It comes down to the backup software loaded into the hard disk.

Answers: WD Elements vs Passport and Seagate Expansion vs GoFlex

Usually this software comes with backup features and passport protection and file recover. The extra money you are paying as opposed to the cheaper version is for the software.

Without Software

  • WD Elements series
  • Seagate Expansion Hard Drives

With Software

  • WD Passport series (WD SmartWare software)
  • Seagate FreeAgent GoFlex (FreeAgent software)

Answers: WD Elements vs. Passport and Seagate Expansion vs GoFlex

Depending on your needs, you might want a passport protect-able portable 2.5 inch hard disk or a hassle free sync feature that just works.

Which Is A Better External Hard Disk?

My 2 primary choices are Western Digital and Seagate. Both are equally good in term of quality and reliability.

For your information, Western Digital just purchased Hitachi Hard Disk division, and Maxtor was bought by Seagate long ago.

I avoid companies that produce everything under the sun, such as HP, Acer, Samsung, LG, Iomega, Toshiba and more. The reason being that these companies are not experts in the hard disk and storage industry, and they are more likely to re-badge hard disk from WD or Seagate. Why pay more?

Hard Drive Buying Advice

10 comments on “Answers: WD Elements vs. Passport and Seagate Expansion vs. GoFlex

  1. Gravatar

    Best External Hard Drives For PC 2013?

  2. Gravatar
    ZamZam [ Reply ]

    Compare Seagate Expansion External Hard Drive

  3. Gravatar
    Richi Jennings [ Reply ]

    Western Digital is a much more solid company

    • Gravatar
      Preston Gralla [ Reply ]

      seagate barracuda rocks… awesome build quality

  4. Gravatar
    Boyman [ Reply ]

    my western digital network drives crippled, you tell me, which is better seagate or western digital?

  5. Gravatar

    Which one isn’t hardware encrypted, old hate to lose hd contents because the USB sata interface board failed.

    • Gravatar
      Geckoandfly [ Reply ]

      I think all of them are software based. Hardware based is too costly for consumer.

  6. Gravatar

    Seagate Expansion 2.5′ –> FAIL (less than a month) !!!
    How It’s happen?
    If I buy 5, It’s will lost 1 in less than a month.
    User error?

    • Gravatar
      Ngan Tengyuen [ Reply ]

      Probably luck. Bad luck. I believe both WD and Seagate are quality hard disk, way better than Hitachi, Samsung and etc. I still use Seagate and WD. But I prefer WD, just my personal opinion.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *